Up until this morning, there was still strong hope that Congress would not eliminate the Federal electric vehicle tax credit, but a late amendment puts the credit in significant doubt. Or did it?
When I woke up this morning I found the text of the Senate bill H.R.1 – Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that was passed last night and skimmed through it looking for anything about the Federal electric vehicle tax credit. I didn’t find anything and so was encouraged that in reconciliation between the Senate and House tax plans, the EV tax credit might remain intact. As a reminder, the House’s version of the tax bill eliminated the tax credit, whereas the Senate version kept the tax credit intact.
Then I came across an article over on the Electrek site reporting that during the revision process to the Senate bill, an amendment was added by Senator Flake that would terminate the credit. (See amendment screenshot below)
Hmm. OK, so why wasn’t this amendment in the final version of the Senate bill? And then in a Twitter exchange with a @ChardCardwell he pointed out that he thought that “lie on the table” means the Flake amendment was rejected.
So in doing my own research, it appears that “lie on the table” means that the amendment was postponed, but could be considered again in the future.
And then this document, “The Amending Process in the Senate,” was also relayed to me where I found this: “… and then moving to lay it on the table. If the Senate agrees to this non-debatable motion, the amendment is considered to be rejected or tabled.”
Confused yet? (Note: Clearly an expert on Congressional legislation is needed at this point, but we’ll forge ahead based on what we understand at this point.)
Things now appear more confusing than ever, but if the Flake amendment was not included in the final version of the Senate bill, then there remains some hope the credit could survive in the reconciliation process. Regardless, the two versions of the tax bills now will go to committee for reconciliation where once revised and a single bill is agreed upon, the legislation must be voted on again.
A big concern, however, is that in the context of all of the other elements of the tax bills – the EV tax credit is just not that important to members of Congress. As such, during the reconciliation process, committee Senators might concede to dropping the credit in return for House members conceding one of their proposals that different from the Senate version.
In short, however, we appear to be no closer to an answer on the status of the tax credit and it likely remains a 50-50 chance that it will survive.
Preparing for Elimination of the Tax Credit
Unlike many electric vehicle advocates, I don’t believe that the loss of the tax credit will be devastating to sales of EVs in the US. As I wrote in ‘Edmunds: “Elimination of federal tax credits likely to kill U.S. EV market” (wrong)’, comparing what happened when the state of Georgia eliminated their state credit is a mistake. The loss of the Georgia credit was devastating to sales of the Nissan LEAF because it became incredibly cheap to purchase. Some LEAF owners in Georgia referred to it as “almost being free” when the Federal and state credits and other benefits were added together. But the decline in sales of other EVs such as the Tesla Model S and BMW i3, was minimal.
The loss of the Federal EV tax credit would have a negligible negative impact on EV sales the next few years, much less than many “the sky will fall” observers predict. I’ll dive more deeply into the effects of the loss of the credit in a future article, but here a few high-level points:
- Lower-Cost EVs: EVs such as the Fiat 500e, Nissan LEAF, smart electric drive, Kia Soul EV, Ford Focus and Toyota Prius Prime that are the least expensive options, could see a sharp drop in sales. The new LEAF with longer range and Prius Prime, which just became the top-selling PHEV, could see the largest decline in sales in 2018.
- On the Fence Consumers: Middle-income consumers who have been considering an EV, but for whom the net effect of a lease payment (with the tax credit built into the payment) potentially being $50-$100 more per month, for example, may be priced out of buying an EV.
- PHEV versions of Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) Models: Directly comparable vehicles such as the Ford Focus Energi and several PHEV versions of BMW, Mercedes and Volvo models which can cost from $5000-$20,000 more than their non electric versions could be hit hard. In these cases, with the tax credits ranging between about $3,000-$5,000, consumers may have used the tax credit to help justify the higher prices of the same model vehicle.
- Middle of the Country Buyers: Early adopting consumers on the West and East coasts are more likely to purchase EVs because of their green signaling and tendency toward “conspicuous conservation.” Whereas it is likely that many more consumers in regions of the US that lag in EV adoption will still need more convincing and understanding of the practical benefits of EVs, before they will make a purchase. While this is a broad and stereotyped generalization, I would expect states with low rates of EV sales to remain so for the next few years.
Areas where I expect very little impact from a loss of the tax credit, include:
- Tesla Models S and X. The tax credit tends to be a nice to have, rather than a must have, for upper-income buyers of these models starting at about $80,000 or more.
- Tesla Model 3: With an estimated more than 400,000 Model 3 reservations and the tax credit estimated to phase out completely to zero dollars in Q4 2019 or Q1 2020, the impact on the Model 3 is hard to gauge. If say 20% of reservation holders cancelled or postponed purchases because of the loss of the tax credit, there would likely still be a greater number of remaining reservation holders to step in and take their place. And so over the long term, Tesla might see fewer Model 3 purchases, but during the next few years there will likely still be more demand than supply.
- Chevrolet Bolt: We could see a slight decline or slowing in the current and continuous climb in Bolt sales. But, with the Bolt now firmly locked in as America’s favorite “affordable” BEV, it should not be overly affected by a loss of the tax credit.
Whether the Federal EV tax credit is eliminated or remains intact, sales of EVs this month are likely going to be a December to remember.